Does this need to be said AGAIN?

Posted on by

Hey, it’s my turn to tag in.  *slaps Nanci’s hand*  I can do this.  If you look back in the archives, I’ve got a post called Why Star Wars Needs Women.  Why don’t you go read that while I drag out the soapbox?

You know, this soapbox keeps getting heavier.  It seems like it keeps getting more difficult to step on to, too.  I know it’s my own perception, though.  It has nothing to do with the actual weight of the soapbox or my own strength.  It has everything to do with exhaustion.  You see, I’m tired.  

You know why?  Because I have to keep repeating myself.  Because I have to keep shouting myself hoarse and jumping up and down and saying “HEY YOU, HOW ABOUT THE GIRLS?”

People conveniently forget that women invented science fiction.  (Haven’t read Frankenstein?  You should.)  They don’t know that the history of science has been rewritten to excise the contributions of hundreds of women.  They don’t realize that there are systematic social roadblocks in the way of women and minorities entering into science and technology.  Don’t believe me?  Maybe you’ll believe Neil DeGrasse Tyson in his response to the man who used to be the president of Harvard University.

Tyson points out that to have women and minorities in science, “[Y]ou gotta come up with a system where there’s equal opportunity.”  You know how some of that starts?  With representation in media.  Don’t believe me?  Take a look at the original Star Trek and the influence that its intentional representation had.  (And yeah, I’ve called JJ out on screwing that up in the Star Trek reboot too.)  Star Wars can’t do that?

Star Wars can do better.

So why am I so tired?  Because when we get a casting list like this, it seems like all the work I do, everything I work for, everything I try to teach my cousins and my students, everything–has been worth precisely a hill of beans.

But Tyson points something else out.  To become an astrophysicist, he says “I looked to become something that was outside the paradigms of expectation of the people in power. Fortunately, my depth of interest was so deep, and so fuel-enriched, that every one of these curveballs I was thrown, and fences built in front of me, and hills that I had to climb, I just reached for more fuel and I kept going.”

So here we go.  Yeah, it needs to be said.  Again.  And we’re going to keep saying it.

9 thoughts on “Does this need to be said AGAIN?”

  3. Part of this cast is also chosen for the next two episodes. IMHO, if the new big three includes Daisy, then I don’t think that is doing too bad. It is a little hard to judge without knowing the relevant importance of the characters.

    • Okay, let’s break it down by JUST the new cast (even though that’s a completely arbitrary way to do it)

      1/7 are female.

      Yup. That’s not good either.

    • You must be new here.

      Why shouldn’t the little girls have more than one choice in heroines? The boys get to be Luke or Han or Chewie or Lando. The girls get…Leia. What if they don’t identify with Leia? So, too bad?

      Women make up half of the population. I don’t think it’s too much to ask to see more than 1/7 in a cast. Because believe it or not, Star Wars is for girls too.

      • I’ve sure learned a lot about Star Wars casting in the last week – it was good to learn about how passionate movie fans are about women having central roles in the story but not so good to learn people are quick to dismiss such ideas in an impolite manner.

        I wonder if the ratios could be improved slightly by assuming Serkis is a CGA character or would that not matter?

        • It’s kind of disingenuous to say Serkis as a CGI character makes things better. The ratios are still bad even if he’s not a white male on screen.

  4. Pingback: Four Points of Clarification | Tosche StationTosche Station

  5. Pingback: Tosche Station Radio #85: It's Really Happening | Tosche StationTosche Station

Comments are closed.